If it's your first derby, run lane rotation. Every car runs every lane, it takes a minute to explain to a room full of parents, and nobody can argue with the result. Pick any other pinewood derby race format later, once you've seen how a day goes.
My first year, I made our format up from nothing. I didn't look at what other groups did. By year two I'd read about the formats and knew far more, and I wish I'd done that reading first.
Lane rotation, the fair format
Every car runs every lane the same number of times. The track can't be blamed, because the lanes were shared equally. That's the whole point, and it's why the results are hard to argue with. If you want the schedule side, I wrote about how lane rotation works, and the lane rotation finals guide covers the finals choices in our race builder.
The downside is that a lot of the races don't feel like they matter. Nobody gets knocked out, so the crowd has no reason to lean in on race 12 of 40.
Rank by times, not places
Rank the cars by their times, not by where they finished in each heat. A time tells you how close the heat was, and a place throws that away. Times are far better, and it isn't close.
Ranking by place, with points for first, second and so on, is only worth doing in a first year when you don't have a timer yet, and you mostly want to get people interested. After that, get an electronic timer as soon as you can.
Single elimination, the exciting format
A bracket is more fun to watch than anything else. Everyone can see the matchups coming. A kid can follow their car's path from round to round, and every family builds their own story. There's an elimination race happening all the time, so every heat matters.
A bracket needs a size that fits the track: the number of lanes times 2, 4, 8 and so on. On a four-lane track, that means 8, 16, 32 or 64 cars. Anyone beyond that is cut after qualifying. In our software the winner of each heat moves on, and the fastest of the rest fill the remaining spots. The bracket guide goes through every bracket setting.
The cost is that one bad heat ends a car's day. A jump or a stuck start can end it for reasons the kid never controlled.
The pinewood derby race format I run
We run free practice first, two races for every car. Then two qualifying races each, which set the brackets. Then a single-elimination bracket, one for the kids and one for the adults, which I call the grand prix. Then a lane rotation final.
The final is there to bring it back to fair. Last year, of about 40 cars, the four in the final ranked 1st, 3rd, 4th and 7th in qualifying. The final eight were 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 10 and 11. That's close to a fair result, and it keeps the room loud all the way through.
It's also a mess to plan, and it's harder than it needed to be. Don't do it first.
Give the adults their own bracket
The adult bracket isn't an afterthought. It's what got our derby going. Another dad and I found an old wooden track in a storage room while we were clearing out chairs, and we both remembered racing as kids. That's all it took. The nostalgia was ours before it was the kids'.
It's also the part that grows. We had about 8 adults the first year and around 15 by the third, so it nearly doubled. I'm going from memory on those, but the direction is right. And they're having a ton of fun. A separate bracket gives them somewhere to race without taking a spot from a kid, and it keeps the parents from racing the kids' cars. If you're deciding which format to run, plan for the adults from the start.
Add a slowest race
A four-lane bracket needs 8, 16, 32 or 64 cars. We usually have about 40 kids, so 32 make the bracket and 8 are cut. Those 8 race each other in a small bracket where the slowest car that finishes moves on, and the last one across the line wins. We only run it for the kids, because we have 10 to 15 adults.
It has to cross the finish line. If it doesn't, you can't judge it. Two years ago a car stopped exactly on the line, and then crept across and ticked the timer. The room was electric.
It's always one of the biggest races of the day, and you don't need a bracket to run one. It works with lane rotation too, and it's still fun. I highly suggest it. Here's how to set up a slowest car race.
Decide on jumps before race day
Single elimination goes wrong in one way. A car jumps its lane, or the start fails, and the whole room looks at you to see what happens next.
Once, a slower car came off the track and hit a fast car. We re-ran the heat and everything was fine in the end, but for that moment people weren't happy, and it wasn't something I could control. That tension is why this needs saying before the first heat.
Two cases need to be discussed and announced. One is a car that comes off on its own. The other is a car that takes out someone else's. You don't need a different rule set for each, but both need to be said out loud. Right now ours is that if your car affects another car, we re-run the heat, and if yours just comes off, we don't.
The case I haven't solved is a really fast car that comes off twice. Does it get 9.999 seconds, which is what the software gives a car that doesn't finish, or does the run not count? It can change the results, and we've gone back and forth. I don't have a good answer.
Apex Derby gives you two tools for it. "Don't count this run" works on any single run. In a times race there's also a setting that throws out each car's slowest qualifying run once it has three, but never in the finals. Neither one is a policy, so settle yours before the day, and say it twice.
How each format works in the race builder
Each format has its own guide, with screenshots of the race builder's choices:
- Lane rotation finals and timed runs: no finals, a final per category, or one combined.
- Single elimination brackets: qualifying, bracket sizes, wildcards, the opening round and the final.
- The championship round: the top cars from earlier races meet in one more race.
- The slowest car race: the slowest car that crosses the line wins.
- Practice runs, fun races and your own heat list: the races that don't count.