Skip to main content
← All Resources
Event planningOctober 15, 2026 · 5 min read

Pinewood derby voting

Last year we let everyone vote for the best-looking car, with no names and nothing tracked. The cars that won weren't the best built, and they weren't the best looking either. The kids who voted were delighted. I was not.

I'm not blaming the kids. A room full of seven-year-olds with a ballot will vote with their hearts, and their hearts like glitter and the loudest friend in the room. That's a fine way to pick a crowd favourite. It's a bad way to pick a best design. Getting to that took me a few tries.

Pinewood derby voting, version one

I started in what I'll call full blind mode. One phone, one vote, no names, no tracking. It was simple, and nobody could say it was unfair.

Then I remembered that this is a kids' event, and the kids should get to vote too. Plenty of them don't have a phone, so a parent's phone has to carry more than one vote. That's where it gets hard.

Why I didn't just open it up

Open voting is a nightmare. Somebody posts the link in a family group chat, and suddenly everyone has voted a million times.

I tried a code on the display screen next. It changed every five minutes, and you got one vote per code. It kept most people honest, but it was annoying for any family with a few kids, and they were the ones I was trying to include.

Names, and who gets to see them

What I settled on is names. The person with the phone gives a first and last name. Each extra voter gives a first name, and a phone can add up to four of them, so a parent can vote for a child who doesn't have a phone.

The name can be fake. It doesn't matter, because you should know the people at your event. If the list has a lot of very suspect names, go and find those people. If they don't exist, delete them from the voting pool.

Only the team sees any of this. In Apex Derby we get the voters grouped by phone, with flags for things like all four extras used or the same owner name on other phones. We can delete one voter or a whole phone. Nothing public ever shows who voted for what. Each phone gets one ballot, and the database refuses a second vote for the same award. Voting runs for a set time, 20 minutes unless you change it.

It also asks a phone which cars are theirs, and greys those out on that ballot. That's an honour system, not a lock, but it keeps honest families honest.

A crowd favourite and a best design

Last year taught me that purely letting people vote is a really bad idea. This year we're trying two awards. The crowd picks a fan favourite, and a few judges pick the best design.

We haven't run this setup yet, so I can't tell you it works. The judges write down the cars they like, talk through the best-looking ones, and vote on paper, outside the site. The site lets you set a winner by hand, which is how that result gets in.

Top 3, or just pick one

Ranked voting, where each voter picks a top three, gets more people involved. It's in the app, and so is a single pick, which is the easier choice for a small group.

It also depends on who's voting. Our adults fight less for the fastest car and more for the best looking one, so they want a top three. The kids are happy with it too, but they care more about winning the race.

Say how it works before voting opens

Tell the room the rules before you open voting. There's one ballot per phone, extra voters give a name, and the team can see who is voting. People trust a process they understand, and a crowd that knows you're watching the ballot box votes a lot more politely.

Start with one award

Pick one easy award, best design, and run it. You'll get a feel for what your crowd wants, and you can add more awards after that.